Followers or crew?

I’ve been playing quite a bit of Star Trek Online of late and one of that game’s systems is the Duty Officer (DOff) system. I’d suggest it is rather similar to the garrison followers system in World of Warcraft’s Draenor expansion.

screenshot_2015-09-15-18-52-10

Both systems offer you the chance to collect a roster of NPC characters – named individuals with certain abilities or characteristics. These characteristics in various combinations make each NPC more or less suited to complete specific tasks or missions. Both games present you with a randomly available set of such missions and you can then send one or more of these NPCs off on the mission. The mission takes a set amount of time and, if successful, will bring back some rewards – usually a low value amount of the game’s main currency or currencies.

WoWScrnShot_090515_202715

Similarities

Both systems are what I would call ‘busy work’, they’re little tasks you can be queuing as a background activity to playing the actual game with your character. Both systems offer the chance over time to improve the effectiveness of specific individual NPCs.

Purple is always best

Purple is always best

So there are decisions to be made on which to improve and in what order. There’s also an element of “gotta catch em’ all” (a Pokémon slogan) in that there are a large number of such NPCs to collect as a longer term goal.

I choose you!

Ahm I choose you!

In both games this system is not 100% necessary to your progress and enjoyment of the game, but you’ll certainly benefit from at least a casual engagement with the system.

Differences

There are some subtle differences between the two systems however. WoW’s garrison mission system is only accessible from a mission table – so you have to be at either your garrison or one of the zone outposts in Draenor to interact with the system. The NPCs are closely tied into the storyline as you play through the zones so in general I at least know who each NPC is roughly and in some cases have built a modicum of affection for them.

You quest with or for many potential followers out in the world

You quest with or for many potential followers out in the world

In Star Trek Online you rapidly build up a veritable horde of Duty Officers, I have 60+ already and I play very casually and I often forget to do the missions at the Academy to get free recruits for each of the sub-races for the Klingon faction (Klingon, Gorn, Nausicaan). This rapid multiplication of crew, coupled with their randomised names leaves me less inclined to remember specific NPCs or to become particularly attached to them.

"Emergency Medical Hologram: Explosives Expert" - now there's a catchy name!

“Emergency R&D Hologram: Explosives Expert” – now there’s a catchy name!

One aspect that I prefer from STO though is the placement of missions. In WoW (as mentioned above) you access missions from any console, a purely utilitarian method that has little connection to the world of Draenor.

WoWScrnShot_091715_211909

In STO the selection of DOff missions available is a feature of where you are in the game. Normally I set off missions at the start of a session, invariably that’s parked in orbit of Qo’nos, and I set off another set of missions at the end of the session from the same location. But while warping around the Alpha or Beta quadrants I also get to run a few DOff mission specific to that nebula, planet or other location. There are even special DOff mission location icons on the sector map.

screenshot_2014-06-10-20-47-25

So in STO the theme of DOff missions and their potential rewards are tied at least in part to where you are in the game. That at least encourages you to move around more in the ‘open world’ than does the garrison system in WoW. There’s also some suitably Klingon-themed missions under the ‘personal’ category – things like executing insubordinate DOffs for instance!

All in all both systems add something extra to their respective games. They offer a reason to login to the respective game even if time is limited, but I would say neither is so absorbing that they alone would be a reason to keep playing if my interest in the actual content were to wane.

P.S. I deliberately have limited this post to just two games, both because I’m currently playing those and because I felt the two systems occupied similar places within the wider game. For instance I haven’t included SWTOR’s companion system in this post because companions are active combat pets as well as being the NPCs for the crafting mission system.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Gaming, STO, WoW. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Followers or crew?

  1. Meznir says:

    One interesting thing: it could be said that the large number of followers from WoW’s inn (you get one follower every week) could result in a detachment from caring about them; however quite a few of them, I do. Why? They aren’t randomly generated – there’s a long list of followers that have been pre-created and a good chunk of care has gone into dressing & gearing them and naming them. Rather than randomly thrown together bits and bobs, many feel like real characters (despite never questing or talking to them) and many have lovely gear (especially when upgraded in ilevel) that I’d love to copy.

    One particular inn character I actually care about is called Nicolas Divide ( http://www.wowhead.com/npc=87955/nicholas-divide ), to start with I really liked his look, but when I read on wowhead that he’s in honor of a player who died in a motorcycle accident, it REALLY made me care about him and swear never to deactivate him.

    I’ve really enjoyed followers in WoD and it’s a real shame we’re not taking them with us into Legion (instead we are getting a small group of Champions).

  2. Shintar says:

    Doffs in STO can also die as far as I remember. I don’t think that happens in WoW?

  3. Telwyn says:

    @Shintar yes, they certainly can in missions anyway if you get a “disaster” result – Klingon captains are even tempted to execute them or permanently banish them for substantial dilitihium rewards..

    @Meznir I’ll try the Inn on my second playthrough so I get to see more followers, they really are nicely designed.

    • Meznir says:

      You should add the inn when you get 100 and an extra slot – gives you treasure missions and you can choose treasure hunter followers. = MONEY!

Comments are closed.